Woman Refusing To Wear ‘Skimpy’ Maid Outfit To Party Backed

The internet has come together in support of a woman who refused to wear a revealing costume to a party, at the request of her friend’s boyfriend.

A 22-year-old woman, known as r/ProfessionalDonut296 on Reddit, shared her predicament on the popular forum “Am I The A******?”, explaining that her housemate, also 22, had recently started dating an affluent man, whom she finds questionable.

The man invited both women to a themed party, where he assigned them specific outfits.

“He sent my friend a picture of our outfits: two skimpy as hell maid costumes sprawled on a bed.

“I immediately told her that I wouldn’t be wearing that s*** and especially not to a party with a bunch of strangers. Initially she thought I was kidding but then understood that I’m serious,” the OP recounted in her post, which received 11,000 upvotes.

While her friend accused her of overreacting, the OP found it humiliating that they, two women of lesser means, were expected to wear maid outfits.

The friend dismissed the OP’s concerns, attributing the request to a “weird rich people thing.”

“I told her again that I will not be wearing some skimpy a** maid costume. Not only is it embarrassing, it is especially disrespectful to me because I don’t have any sort of meaningful relationship with the guy, and yet he thought it’s appropriate to include me in this request.

“I told her that I won’t be wearing the clothes, won’t be going to the party, and will from now on avoid her new bf altogether,” she continued.

Despite standing firm, the decision led to a heated argument. Her friend accused her of being a killjoy and unsupportive, while the guy even offered to pay the OP to attend, which only fueled her anger.

Feeling conflicted but determined to maintain her boundaries, OP shared the situation with her dad. As the party drew closer, her friend was planning to attend alone and was barely speaking to her.

“Am I the a******? Or is she? I feel strangely very guilty even though I’m standing up for my boundaries. AITA?” OP asked.

Expert Insight

Adam Horvath, a psychologist with Personal Psychology, Sydney, Australia, weighed in on the situation. He emphasized the importance of setting clear boundaries, especially when someone feels uncomfortable or pressured.

“Not wanting to wear a specific costume isn’t about being a ‘killjoy’; it’s about maintaining personal comfort,” he told Newsweek.

He added that while it’s crucial to communicate boundaries respectfully, friends should also prioritize each other’s well-being and understand each other’s feelings without pressuring one another.

Kristie Tse, a psychotherapist from Dallas, Texas, emphasized that the woman’s refusal to wear the costume demonstrates the importance of maintaining personal boundaries, especially when faced with uncomfortable or disrespectful requests.

“It’s crucial to address that her decision to not participate is valid and aligns with her sense of self-respect. The friend’s reaction to her refusal highlights a common issue in relationships where differing values and expectations clash,” she told Newsweek.

To navigate this situation, Tse advises:

• Respect for Personal Boundaries: The woman was correct in asserting her limits, as it’s crucial to respect personal comfort levels, which can vary among individuals.
• Effective Communication: The woman should communicate openly with her friend, making it clear that her refusal wasn’t a critique of the friend’s choices but rather a matter of personal comfort and respect. Clear, empathetic communication can help resolve misunderstandings.
• Evaluating the Friendship: If the friend continues to disregard her boundaries, it may be necessary to reassess the friendship. A healthy relationship should respect and honor individual differences and boundaries.

Reddit Reacts

Reddit overwhelmingly supported OP, declaring her not the a*****.

“That’s disgusting. This guy is a huge red flag. Huuuge. Your friend is terribly naive,” commented accidentallywitchy.

“NTA [not the a******]. You’re sticking to your guns—’what if I paid you?’ tells you everything you need to know about what this d-bag thinks of women,” another user added.

Concern for OP’s friend was a common theme among the comments.

“I know your friend is angry with you, but could you convince her to check in with you a few times during the party? Just a few quick texts to make sure she’s ok. This whole situation is so gross and sketchy,” suggested shes_crafty_4301.

Newsweek reached out to u/r/ProfessionalDonut296 for comment via Reddit.

Newsweek’s “What Should I Do?” offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek.